On this page
They all generate the same codes
Here is the part comparison articles often skip: for standard TOTP accounts, every authenticator app produces exactly the same codes. They all implement the same open standard, RFC 6238, so a key added to Google Authenticator, Authy, Microsoft Authenticator, or a password manager will show identical digits at the same moment.
That means the real differences are not about security of the codes themselves. They are about backup, sync, export, device support, and extra features. Choose based on how you want to handle a lost phone and whether you might want to switch apps later.
App features change over time, so treat the details below as a snapshot and check the current app store listing before deciding.
Google Authenticator
Strengths: simple, free, widely recognised, and available on Android and iPhone. It can optionally sync your codes to your Google account, so a new phone can restore them after you sign in. It also has a built-in transfer accounts feature that exports codes as QR codes, which you can scan on another device. Our export decoder can read those QR codes if you want to see the keys inside.
Weaknesses: few extras. No desktop app. Sync is tied to a Google account, which some people prefer to avoid for privacy reasons, and if you use it without sync you must remember to transfer before changing phones.
Good for: people who want something straightforward and already use Google services.
Microsoft Authenticator
Strengths: works as a normal TOTP app for any service, and adds push approvals and passwordless sign-in for Microsoft personal, work, and school accounts. Many workplaces using Microsoft Entra ID require it. It offers cloud backup, using iCloud on iPhone and a Microsoft account on Android.
Weaknesses: heavier than a pure code generator, and backup restores do not cross between iPhone and Android. Microsoft has also trimmed non-authenticator features such as password autofill, so do not choose it as a password manager.
Good for: anyone whose employer uses Microsoft 365, and people who live in the Microsoft ecosystem.
Authy
Strengths: encrypted cloud backup and multi-device sync, protected by a backup password you set. Popular for years because it made changing phones painless.
Weaknesses: its desktop apps were discontinued in 2024, so it is now mobile only. Backups are tied to your phone number. Most importantly, Authy has never offered a straightforward way to export your secret keys, which makes moving away from it tedious: you usually have to reset 2FA on each account one by one.
Good for: people who value easy restore and do not expect to switch apps. If portability matters to you, weigh the lack of export carefully.
Open-source apps and password managers
The big three are not the only choices. Two other categories deserve a look:
- Open-source authenticators such as Aegis (Android), 2FAS, and Ente Auth publish their code, offer encrypted backups or exports you control, and make it easy to move to another app. They are excellent if you want transparency and no lock-in.
- Password managers such as Bitwarden, 1Password, and others can store TOTP keys next to the password and autofill the code. This is very convenient and makes backups automatic. The trade-off is that both factors live in one vault, so the vault's own security, especially its master password and its own 2FA, becomes critical. Many people keep their most important accounts (email, the password manager itself) in a separate authenticator.
Where browser-based generators fit
Browser-based TOTP generators, including our own TOTP generator, compute codes from a key you paste in. Done properly, the calculation happens entirely in your browser and nothing is uploaded. They are useful for:
- Developers testing a 2FA implementation, sometimes with many keys at once using a bulk 2FA code generator.
- Checking that a saved key still produces valid codes.
- Emergencies, when you have a backed-up key but no phone.
- Learning how TOTP works.
They are not a great primary authenticator for important accounts. A web page is a less controlled environment than a dedicated app, and you have to supply the key each time or store it somewhere. Our guide Is an online 2FA generator safe? covers what to check.
Questions to ask before you commit
Instead of picking by brand, run any candidate app through these questions:
- What happens if I lose my phone? Is there an encrypted backup, and do I control the password protecting it?
- Can I leave? Is there an export that gives me my keys, or am I locked in?
- Which devices does it run on? Phone only, or also tablet and desktop?
- Can I lock the app itself with a PIN or biometrics, so someone holding my unlocked phone cannot read codes?
- Does it handle non-default settings, such as 8 digits or SHA-256, if any of my services need them?
An app that answers all five well will serve you for years.
So which should you use?
- Want simple and free: Google Authenticator with sync turned on, or an open-source app with encrypted backup.
- Work uses Microsoft 365: Microsoft Authenticator, at least for work accounts.
- Want no lock-in and full control: Aegis, 2FAS, or Ente Auth.
- Want maximum convenience: a reputable password manager with TOTP support, while keeping your email and vault 2FA in a separate app or on a security key.
- Testing or development: a client-side browser generator.
Whatever you pick, save backup codes for every important account. No app choice matters more than having a way back in when a phone goes missing.
Frequently asked questions
Are codes from different authenticator apps interchangeable?
Yes, for standard TOTP accounts. Every compliant app uses the same algorithm, so the same secret key produces the same code in any of them at the same time. Push approvals and passwordless sign-in are app-specific features, though, and do not transfer between apps.
Which authenticator app is the most secure?
The code generation is equally secure in all reputable apps. Differences come from backups, app locks, and how easy recovery is for you versus an attacker. An app with encrypted backup, a device lock, and a strong recovery plan is a sensible choice regardless of brand.
Can I move my accounts out of Authy?
Not easily. Authy does not offer an official export of secret keys. The reliable method is to sign in to each service, disable or reset 2FA, and set it up again in your new app, which is tedious but also gives you fresh keys and backup codes.
Can I use two authenticator apps for the same account?
Yes. If you scan the same QR code into two apps during setup, both will show matching codes. This is a simple form of backup, but each extra copy is another place your secret lives, so only add it to devices you trust.